General Impressions and Form Factor
I've set aside my Nokia phone for a new Samsung Captivate
Galaxy S phone from AT&T. Here's a quick overview of the device.
I can't resist making some comparisons to the benchmark of smartphones, Apple's iPhone (though I'll keep them casual). On removal from the box I was struck by the quality of the feel. the case is dominated by the 4" glass screen (the display is slightly larger than that of an iPhone). Unlike the glass back of the iPhone 4, the Captivate has a sturdy plastic case that feels more like enameled metal than plastic. The removable back cover is metal with a carbon fiber finish, and looks great up close. Those who are frustrated with the iPhone's lack of a removable battery and SDRAM card will be pleased to hear that the Captivate has both. The SDRAM card is hidden under the back cover. It's easily removed and replaced without disturbing the battery, and yet is well protected by the cover.
There are only two ports on this phone, which makes a lot of sense, considering that one of the ports is a MicroUSB port and the other is for a standard 3.5 mm miniphono headset jack. Lovely; there's no excuse for proprietary ports these days. The MicroUSB port at the top of the device is protected, not by a flappy rubber plug, but by a sliding cover. Nice. Rounding out the physical controls are the power button, on the upper right; the volume controls, on the left; and four dedicated touchpads just under the SAMSUNG logo. These are, in order: the Context Menu, Home, Back, and Search. These last four are used quite a lot, so it makes sense to put them on physical buttons in predictable locations, and it relieves developers from having to devote screen space to these functions. In addition to the physical port, you can get info into and out of the device on the SDRAM card (up to 32GB); through the WiFi radio (802.11b/g/n); through the Bluetooth 3.0 interface; and of course through the 3G radio. The device also has GPS, an accelerometer, and compass.
Next, I was struck with the performance. Not only is it fast (it's powered by a 1GHz Hummingbird processor), but the 4" AMOLED screen is BRIGHT and highly responsive to touch. The interface is what you should expect from Android 2.2; that is, it's amazing and intuitive. Pinching, swiping, zooming all work exactly as expected.
My biggest frustration in moving devices didn't come from the Captivate. Nokia had updated the desktop software for my 6550 flip-phone, and removed the option to export contacts! Now, this is just petty, and rather than lock a person like me into a device, it encourages me to leave. I ran the backup utility, then used the Open Source NBUExplorer
software to export the contacts to individual vCard files. From there I went to the command line, issued a "copy *.vcf names.vcf" to put all of the vCards into a single file. I then went to GMail, imported the names.vcf file and used GMail's contacts list to merge, delete, categorize, and generally clean up my phone contacts. There are software packages that can edit vCards, but they're unnecessary if you've got GMail.
This is where the word "amazing" applies. Going back to the Captivate, I prepared to import the list, only to find that I didn't have to. Since I use GMail, the entire contacts list is active and accessible to the phone. I didn't have to do the import at all. AND, contacts I create on the phone are immediately accessible to GMail and GTalk. Every bit of the frustration I felt towards Nokia was balanced out by the delight I felt toward the Android phone.
This weekend I put the phone through a workout. Since it's my twins' birthday weekend, we went for a long drive, and I took the opportunity to try out the GPS navigator. I pulled up the Maps app, clicked the context menu and "Directions", and was greeted with two fields; "My Location" and "End point". "My Location" was self-explanatory, so I clicked in "End point" to type in my destination. I noticed then that there was a microphone icon on the keyboard, so I tapped it and spoke my destination aloud. It correctly interpreted my voice, found the location, and displayed directions. Tapping "Navigate" put it in a mode comparable to a Garmin or other GPS navigator. There were a couple of iffy spots where I lost signal, but it was quickly regained; and I noted that you get much better results if you placed the handset in a spot where it is semi-upright and facing forward. Fortunately my car has such a spot, and everything was golden. The crowning touch was that, upon reaching my destination, the map was replaced by a picture of the building.
On the way home, I decided to try it again with some more general instructions. I said, "Baskin-Robbins, Spartanburg South Carolina", and tapped on one of the two locations I was presented with. VERY nice!
Of course, I've tried some games and apps, and they all work very well. It comes with far more apps than are pictured above, and yes, you CAN get your Angry Birds fix. The apps I'm mainly interested in are eBook readers, of which I recommend Google eBooks
and Amazon Kindle
for Android. I also found the YouVersion Bible app
, the Guided Ways iQuran
, and the Sparsh Bhagavad Gita
to be very usable. Since most of my existing ebooks are in the .PDB format, I would LOVE to use eReader for Android
, but at the moment, I can't. That's because "for your security", AT&T locks out any apps that aren't sourced in the Android Market
. As a developer, I can't say I'm in love with that decision. I'll eventually use a work-around, but I don't want to. So at the moment I encourage AT&T to make this lockout user-configurable and I also encourage eReader.com
to get their software out of perpetual beta and put it in the Android Market. And of course the Captivate does all the Googling and Facebooking and Twittering you can stand. Except for Gmail I'm turning it all off... I've seen people who are slaves to the beeping things on their hips, and it's not pretty.
Another thing I'm not thrilled with is the battery life. It is said that it has a 5 hour battery life when in use, and something like 300 hours on standby. Ugh. There are so many useful apps and features that you'll never see 300 hours. If you're addicted to YouTube or Angry Birds you'll never see 5 hours. Realistically, this phone will live on the charger whenever a power source is available. That's a major disappointment for someone who's used to a Palm device that could go for a week between charges. The good news is that the Captivate replaces my Palm device, my Nokia phone, and my camera. The bad news is that it sucks up as much power as those devices combined. Granted, it's doing more with the power, but gone is gone.There's a power analyzer, so I've learned that the bright AMOLED screen accounts for over 70% of the power use of the device. To maximize the battery life, turn off the screen when not in use. In practice, when I get in the car, it goes on the charger. When I get to my desk it goes on the charger. And dat's da name o' dat tune.
As a camera, it's also very nice. The Captivate has one 5 megapixel camera (2560 x 1920 pixels) with auto-focus, smile detection, digital zoom, digital zoom, multi-shot, effects, self-timer, panorama, and ISO control. It can capture video at 720p HD (that's 1280 x 720 pixels). In other words, it's got a bunch of junk I'll rarely, if ever, use. The inclusion of self-timer begs a question... If you're going to take a self-shot with the timer, how do you expect to position the phone???
A camera has a screw socket to hold it in a tripod. Not so with this phone. So how to do it? Apparently I'm not the only one who's been pondering this question: here's a thread
Now, this is the point of the review where I realize that I've completely neglected to review the phone as a phone. So here it is... it's great. Pressing the Phone button gives you a keypad. Above it there's a Contacts button and a Favorites button, both of which give you access to your contacts. You browse contacts either by swiping the list up and down or by jumping to an index. Slide the contact to the right for a voice call, or slide it to the left for text messaging. And remember the voice recognition...? It works in text messaging, too, and is very good. I used the name of a pub, "Brewmeisters" in a text, and voice recognition got the spelling right, so I'll forgive it for splitting the name into two words.
The sound is simply stellar. The speakerphone is loud and clear, and the microphone is clear. The phone implements software noise cancellation. I'd say it works, as the people I called disbelieved it was a cell phone, much less a cell phone on speaker.
All in all, I'm very happy with it so far. The battery life is a downer, but as it's charged through a fairly standard microUSB port I'm not going to sweat it. The bells and whistles are worth it. In a roomful of iPhones you will not feel the slightest bit ashamed to whip this out.